Is Cancel Culture the New Shaming?

Guest Blog

Cancel culture is rife throughout our country today. Essentially, this is a contemporary form of ostracism, in which someone is eliminated socially or professionally, typically online, on social media, or even in person.

Last week, cancel culture took on a whole new meaning at a Florida high school. Upon receiving their highly anticipated yearbooks, scores of teenage girls found that certain parts of their bodies had simply vanished from their portraits. Primarily, these deletions were confined to bare shoulders and chests that suggested even the smallest hint of cleavage. Approximately 80 photos were obviously and clumsily “adjusted” by digital alteration. Another clever ploy was to place a black box on the photo, effectively canceling a female student’s chest.

School officials defended this action by claiming the photos were a violation of dress code policy. It appears that this administration is inordinately concerned with modesty, but only with the female students. With that said, no warning was given to anyone in advance of the yearbook’s release and no parent or student was given the opportunity to provide another photo option. In other words, these young girls excitedly flipped through the yearbook, only to discover their personal photos had been defaced.

Consider this: only female students were targeted, and shirtless photos of male students remained untouched. Even more egregious, the boy’s swim team was photographed in speedo swimsuits.

Does the term “double standard” or the word “discrimination come to mind? It is important to note that 78% of dress code violations district-wide went to female students.

For decades, adolescent girls have served as the official punching bag for those skilled in the art of shaming. Our perfection-driven society and the media are common culprits, but they are not alone. On every possible social media outlet, vulnerable, impressionable girls are daily told they are ugly, stupid, and pathetic. Fat shaming is a given. Bullies, who remain safely anonymous, relentlessly inform teenagers that suicide is their only recourse. Sadly, certain girls follow this instruction, thus ending the bullying forever.

This is precisely why countless numbers of females suffer with extreme body hatred and self-condemnation. In turn, depression, anxiety and certainly eating disorders are escalating at an alarming rate.

Although teenage girls are mercilessly criticized, according to school officials in Florida, the negative body-image list wasn’t quite thorough enough.

Now in addition to acne-riddled skin, unattractive hair and too much weight on the scale, these young students must be shamed for their burgeoning sexuality.

It is time for gender-discriminating, archaic rules such as these to be reconsidered and revised.

In a completely unrelated, but equally disturbing turn of events regarding children, last Friday Facebook revealed its new business venture. The company is hoping to extend their widely popular Instagram app to younger users, specifically those under 13. Currently, this population sector is prohibited from usage due to federal privacy regulations. Supposedly, this expanded app is intended to be a parent-controlled experience.

The announcement by Facebook, not surprisingly, was met with various degrees of outrage from those in the behavioral health field. And for good reason. Currently social media does far more damage than good when it comes to adolescents. Likes and dislikes, the advent of FOMO, reality vs filters and photo manipulation has created an entire generation of insecure, self-absorbed adolescents.

And now Mark Zuckerberg wants to infiltrate an even younger, more easily influenced group? His motivation is clear: start them young to ensure a life-long connection to Facebook-related apps. Developmentally, most children cannot even distinguish between real text and advertisements.

We at SunCloud Health hope this effort to expand the influence of Instagram fails. These young children must be protected from the inevitability of social media for as long as possible. Just let them be kids for a little longer—allow them to live in a child’s world of fantasy, make-believe, nature, and imagination. Give them just a little more time to interact with others face-to-face, instead of via a screen. Instagram, along with other apps, will get them soon enough.

-Our Research Team-
Timothy D. Brewerton, MD, DLFAPA, FAED, DFAACAP, CEDS-S
Professor Emeritus of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences
Dr. Christopher Womack
Medical Director, Child and Adolescent Psychiatry

Dr. Christopher Womack joins SunCloud as our Medical Director, Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.

Dr. Womack is board certified in Adult as well as Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, attending the University of Chicago Pritzker School of Medicine. Adult psychiatry residency and child fellowship training were completed at the University of Chicago Medical Center.

Dr. Womack’s treatment  philosophy hinges on strength based, evidence informed care, where collaboration is central to guiding individualized treatment.  He has experience caring for children and teens from varied backgrounds, appreciating the importance of how identity can inform treatment.

Favorite pastimes are cooking new recipes and exploring Chicago’s rich cultural diversity through its neighborhood and fine dining experiences.

Elizabeth E. Sita, MD
Medical Director of Adult Services

Dr. Elizabeth E. Sita, MD, is a Board Certified psychiatrist specializing in the care of patients with eating disorders. She completed her undergraduate training at the University of Chicago and graduated with Highest Honors. She then earned her medical degree at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine and was recognized with the Chairman’s Award for Excellence in Psychiatry. She subsequently completed residency with the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences at McGaw Medical Center of Northwestern University, where she was elected Chief Resident and received the Resident Psychiatrist Leadership & Service Award.

Upon completing her training, Dr. Sita joined the staff atAscension Alexian Brothers Behavioral Health Hospital Hospital, where she served as Assistant Medical Director of the Center for Eating Disorders and Director of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Services before transitioning to lead the new inpatient eating disorder unit as Medical Director of Eating Disorder Services at Ascension Saint Joseph Hospital – Chicago. In these roles, she has cared for a multitude of adolescents and adults struggling with anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, binge eating disorder, and other eating disorders as well as severe, cooccurring mood, trauma, personality, and substance use disorders.

Dr. Sita has been recognized throughout her training and practice for a commitment to excellence in patient care and for her ability to engage patients in their most challenging moments. Her passions include the care of treatment-resistant eating and mood disorders as well as questions of medical capacity and end-of-life decision making.

She believes that, first and foremost, human connection is key to mental health and well-being and strives to share this philosophy in each and every patient encounter. She is excited to bring her expertise to SunCloud Health as the Medical Director of Adult Services!

 

VIDEO: Meet Elizabeth E. Sita, MD, Medical Director of Adult Services

 

Lacey Lemke, PsyD
Assistant Vice President of Clinical Services

Dr. Lacey Lemke (she/her) is a licensed clinical health psychologist with specialized expertise in the treatment of eating disorders and the practice of medical and health psychology. She completed her doctoral training in clinical psychology with a Primary Care emphasis at the Adler School of Professional Psychology. Dr. Lemke went on to complete both her predoctoral clinical internship and postdoctoral fellowship through Ascension Health, where she gained advanced training working with individuals experiencing eating disorders and self-injurious behaviors, as well as within pediatric subspecialty settings including endocrinology, neurology, and adolescent medicine.

Dr. Lemke is deeply committed to providing evidence-based, compassionate care and collaborates closely with interdisciplinary teams to ensure comprehensive treatment. Her professional mission is to support patients in achieving their fullest potential by guiding them to the most appropriate level of care and empowering them to make meaningful, sustainable progress toward improved health and well-being.

VIDEO: 2. Meet Lacey Lemke, PsyD.